The absolution of non-audit services – unravelling a nexus of research: A quantitative study of non-audit services’ impact on financial reporting quality among private firms in Sweden.
2020 (English) Independent thesis Advanced level (professional degree), 20 credits / 30 HE credits
Student thesis Alternative title
Konsultationstjänsters absolution – en utredning av tidigare forskning : En kvantitativ studie av konsultationstjänsters påverkan av den finansiella rapporteringens kvalitet bland svenska privata bolag. (Swedish)
Abstract [en]
Non-audit services provided by audit firms have been a popular scientific topic within the fields of audit and accounting research over the past decades. Numerous researchers have attempted to provide a theoretical contribution by examining different ways of measuring the concepts of audit quality and financial reporting quality. The resulting consequences are mixed results and a lack of consensus among researchers from both research fields. The two, in other situations, rather distinctive research fields of audit quality and financial reporting quality, have, in several cases, been confounded without analytical reflection regarding their differences. In parallel to the scientific progress, regulatory bodies have noticed the increasing trend of non-audit services and how they constitute larger portions of the audit firm’s annual revenues. Their responses have been legal restrictions, both in the US and Europe, in order to cease the trend.
The purpose of this thesis is to make a pronounced investigation regarding the relationship between non-audit services and financial reporting quality in Swedish private firms. Furthermore, it will also be of interest to examine if this proposed relationship is moderated by the presence of the four global market-leading audit firms or not.
The study is based on a deductive approach and a quantitative research strategy, to collect and analyze data from annual reports. To fulfill the purpose of the study, the data is analyzed by conducting binary and multinomial logistic regression tests.
The results suggest that there is an association between certain types of non-audit services and financial reporting quality. Specifically, services that are unrelated to tax have proven to be statistically significant positively correlated with financial reporting quality. No evidence was found supporting a moderating effect by the characteristics of audit firms, suggesting that the choice of an audit firm is irrelevant for attaining high financial reporting quality when purchasing non-audit services.
The study’s theoretical contribution is the novelty arising from the combination of studying non-audit services’ impact on financial reporting quality within a Swedish setting on private firms. The study also provides empirical contribution by using a proxy for financial reporting quality rarely used in previous research. The findings are of practical importance since they suggest that firms potentially benefit in their financial reporting by purchasing these kinds of services, which contradicts past actions made by regulatory bodies.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages 2020. , p. 115
Keywords [en]
Non-audit services, financial reporting quality, qualified auditor report, big four audit firms, knowledge spillover effect, economic dependence, auditor independence
National Category
Business Administration
Identifiers URN: urn:nbn:se:hj:diva-48577 ISRN: JU-IHH-FÖA-2-20201051 OAI: oai:DiVA.org:hj-48577 DiVA, id: diva2:1433274
Subject / course JIBS, Business Administration
Supervisors
Examiners
2020-06-172020-05-292025-10-13 Bibliographically approved